Skip to main content

Based on a true story...

Oh Dear!
I was perusing a movie site—checking for performance times of First Man—when my eyes fell upon an ad for a new film; The Happy Prince, written, directed and starring Rupert Everett, and based on Oscar Wilde's downfall and last years.

What a happy time that will be.
My biggest concern was that First Man is no longer showing in local theaters—its run of a few weeks suggesting that it did not find favor with modern audiences. Most of whom are probably convinced that man never walked on the moon; and would not want to see such nonsense!

But I digress.
For I cannot imagine that a movie about Oscar Wilde's later years will be a happy way to spend an evening. If they don't want to see a movie about successfully landing on the moon, why would they want to see one about abject failure?

I am, of course, annoyed.
I have been working on a short play about Oscar Wilde's last years for a while now, and I am distressed to see someone else making a hash of it before I have finished my effort.
One does not want to appear unoriginal.

I take comfort in the fact that my work will be nothing like the film. My play is so loosely based on the facts as to be total fiction. The film, however, is probably 'based on a true story'—Hollywood's way of saying that it is mostly fiction.

The problem with 'based on a true story' always is; how 'based' is it? So loosely based as to be totally debased?
You can never tell.
A key event portrayed in First Man is when Armstrong leaves something on the moon for his young daughter, who had died years before. This was fabricated by the filmmakers, as there is no record or comment from Armstrong suggesting that he did such a thing.

As an aside, the Emperor may have told Mozart "Too beautiful for our ears, and a powerful lot of notes, dear Mozart!" (though he may have meant the performance was too long)* and Jack and Rose might have survived on the door if they'd used Rose's lifejacket for added buoyancy.

So what to do?
Well, of course, I will probably wait a couple of years before publishing so that everyone will have forgotten about the current movie.
And maybe I'll go and see it—though maybe I shouldn't.



*I was told some years ago that the "And there are simply too many notes" quote was totally fabricated in the movie Amadeus. That annoyed me so much, as I'd loved that moment in the film.
It's something you remember.
But it appears that a quote that is not too different appears in Leben des k.k. Kapellmeisters Wolfgang Gottlieb Mozart nach Originalquellen geschrieben by Franz Xaver Niemetschek, published 1798 ref: Google Groups.
The quote there is: Zu schoen fuer unsere Ohren, und gewaltig viel Noten, lieber Mozart! —
"Too good for our ears, and a lot of notes, dear Mozart!"
We'll ignore the fact that the quote may have been manufactured by that author, because I am sure it is based on a true story.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Grammarly - Inconsistent punctuation fix bug

As I wrote in my previous post ( Grammarly - I think I like it ), I've been using Grammarly to proof my book. I'm still happy with it, but I did discover a problem it has with certain punctuation imported in a Word .docx file. One of Grammarly's features is a fix for 'Inconsistent punctuation.' It was upset that my files (which were .docx files exported from Adobe InDesign ) contained a mix of straight and curly apostrophe and quotation marks. I think the problem is that internally  InDesign fixes these issues in your original text on the fly, but if you export the text it sends out the original formatting rather than changing the punctuation. I figured that making this change in Grammarly was a good idea, but what I discovered is that after doing this, there were instances where single apostrophes and quotation marks were moved, particularly around a 'word' or if I had a single apostrophe next to quotation marks: "And then he shouted 'Fire!&#

Grammarly - I think I like it

I’d seen the ads for Grammarly, a tool that promised to help me “ Compose bold, clear*, mistake-free writing with Grammarly’s AI-powered writing assistant, ” but I was skeptical. Maybe I didn’t want to spend the $139.95 a year it costs (there is also a $29.95 a month option.) [* that sentence came from Grammarly’s website, and Grammarly suggested changing the word clear.] This week I finally tried the free version, just out of curiosity, and after using it I was intrigued enough to get the paid version, a nd though it’s only been a few days, I like it. I’ve been running my book through it, and while we have a lot of disagreements (primarily over Unclear Antecedents), it has found enough spelling errors I had missed, and grammar and punctuation mistakes, to make me feel that it's worth the price. Pros • It finds spelling mistakes and grammar issues that I missed using other tools, and with multiple proof-readings. • It’s easy to use, though performance c

Debugging Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing - Internal Error

I’ve been setting up my next book in Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP.) This is the second book I have published through KDP, and it’s a reasonably straightforward process.   I first uploaded a draft of the book and cover months ago to check that I had the formatting right. This is something I recommend doing; if your text layout goes into the trim area, or has some other problem, the upload will be rejected. You want to make sure your design is right before you finish the layout of your whole book.     Anyway, I just finished the manuscript and went to upload it and the updated cover. When I did, I got an Internal Error for both the cover and the book. That confused me, as I hadn't made significant changes to the formatting. I tried uploading the previous version of the text and cover—the ones that had uploaded successfully some months ago—and got errors on those too!     I tried some different things uploading different versions and managed at one point to get the original cover to